Mitigating the Risks of Resource Extraction for Industrial Actors and Northern Indigenous Peoples

  • Alexis Monique Lerner The University of Toronto; Stanford University http://orcid.org/0000-0002-8700-6696
  • Victoria Koshurina National Research University Higher School of Economics, Department of Sociology
  • Olga Chistanova Khakas State University, Institute of History and Law
  • Angela Wheeler Harvard University, Department of Architecture

Abstract

A collaborative relationship between native peoples and industrial corporations–two actors that value resource-rich land–is of vital importance for both the United States and the Russian Federation. A strong partnership between industrial and indigenous actors can help to ensure not only the stability of extractive projects, but also the protection of indigenous groups from the potentially existential threats associated with territorial loss. Cooperation between these two parties gains urgency as extractive corporations begin to explore the Arctic, a region of the world already home to over two dozen unique indigenous communities. In both the United States and the Russian Federation, there are legal precedents for negotiations regarding indigenous rights, natural resources, and the fuel-energy complex. Even so, parties involved in the extractive process frequently stray from these national and international legal guidelines. Our paper seeks to answer the question: why might rational actors–here, indigenous and industrial communities that are motivated by their preferences–fail to cooperate on extractive projects, even when robust collaborative agreements benefit all sides? We suggest that the explanation is twofold: first, indigenous land rights lack the consistency which may give indigenous communities control over their resources and cultural preservation; and second, a neutral and objective third-party mediator–whether in the form of a state or an international body–is often silent in, or absent from, the negotiation process, thereby undermining its authority to ensure fair and reasonable deliberations. Our findings can offer important insights for community-corporate relations, not only in the Arctic, but worldwide.

(Published: May 2017)

Citation: A.M. Lerner et al. “Mitigating the Risks of Resource Extraction for Industrial Actors and Northern Indigenous Peoples.” Arctic Review on Law and Politics, Vol. 8, 2017, pp. 23–51. http://dx.doi.org/10.23865/arctic.v8.659

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Alexis Monique Lerner, The University of Toronto; Stanford University

University of Toronto, Department of Political Science and

Hebrew University of Jerusalem, The Leonard Davis Institute for International Relations

Stanford University, Director of Research for the Stanford US-Russia Forum

 

Published
2017-05-27
Section
Original Articles
How to Cite
LERNER, Alexis Monique et al. Mitigating the Risks of Resource Extraction for Industrial Actors and Northern Indigenous Peoples. Arctic Review, [S.l.], v. 8, may 2017. ISSN 2387-4562. Available at: <https://arcticreview.no/index.php/arctic/article/view/659>. Date accessed: 19 aug. 2017. doi: https://doi.org/10.23865/arctic.v8.659.

Keywords

natural resources; oil and gas; extraction; indigenous; UNDRIP; negotiations, Arctic